I just hung up on my boss by accident and my phone is sitting on the passenger seat like a dead fish and I know he thinks I am being rude but my hands are shaking from the wind and the cold. I spend my days in a small sedan with teenagers who smell like nervous sweat and energy drinks and I tell them to keep their eyes on the horizon but they always look at the lines on the road instead.
They want the road to tell them what to do and they want the paint to lead them and they forget that the car is a heavy beast that does not care about lines when the ice comes. I am a driving instructor and I know that people see what they expect to see and they miss the truth that is staring them in the face because they are too busy looking for a sign that they are right.
15% Attention
85% Attention
The cognitive tax of seeking permission: we watch the markers, not the world.
The Bird in the Gutter
Claire sat in the middle of the circle and she had the porcelain in her hands and the tissue paper made a sound like dry leaves in a gutter. The group of collectors leaned in and they held their breath and they waited for her to speak. The little box was shaped like a bird and the feathers were painted with a blue that looked like the sky just before a storm and the gold trim around the middle was bright and clean.
Claire did not look at the bird and she did not look at the eyes of the bird and she did not run her finger over the smooth glaze. She turned the bird over and she looked at the bottom of the piece and she squinted her eyes until they were just slits in her face. She said this mark has the specific curve of the and it matches the example in the big red book and suddenly everyone in the room stopped looking at the bird.
They all started to look at the smudge of green ink on the white clay and they started to talk about the factory and the history and the value and the bird died right there in the room. They did not notice that the beak was slightly crooked or that the weight was wrong for the clay of that era and they only wanted to feel the spark of being right. I have seen this happen on the road when a student sees a green light and they think the world is safe and they do not see the truck that is running the red light from the left side. They trust the sign and they ignore the metal.
Reflections of a Lie
I once told a student named Marcus that he should trust the mirrors and I was wrong because mirrors have a way of lying when the sun is at a certain angle. We were pulling out of a lot and I saw a flash of silver in the glass and I told him to go and I did not look over my shoulder and we almost ended up in the hospital because that silver flash was just a reflection of a sign and not a clear path.
I was looking for the thing I expected to see and I found it and I almost killed a boy because of it. I felt the shame in my gut and I felt the heat in my face and I realized that a matching pattern is a cage for the mind.
The Thin Surface of Authenticity
When people look at Limoges France porcelain they often do the same thing that Claire did in that living room. They go straight for the underside and they look for the words that say the piece is from France and they look for the name of a maker they recognize and they let the rest of the box disappear.
The porcelain is thin and it lets the light through and the hinges are fitted by hand with a tiny hammer and a steady eye but none of that matters once the stamp is found. If the stamp looks like the one in the book then the brain stops asking questions and the eyes stop looking at the brush strokes.
This is a communal habit and it is a dangerous way to live because it makes us easy to fool. If you give a person the answer they want to find then they will stop looking for the truth and they will defend the lie because the lie feels like a victory.
I see it in the eyes of the parents who come to pick up their kids after a lesson and they ask me if the kid is ready for the test and they only want to hear me say yes. They do not want to hear that the kid cannot stay in the lane or that the kid does not understand how a four way stop works and they only want the stamp of approval. They want the mark on the paper so they can stop worrying and they can go back to their quiet lives.
The Liar’s Steady Hand
The truth about the porcelain is that the mark is the easiest thing to fake and the hardest thing to trust. A man with a stamp and a steady hand can put any name he wants on the bottom of a piece of clay and he can bake it in an oven and he can wait for someone like Claire to find it.
Validation is a commodity; the click of a hinge and the weight of the clay are a philosophy.
But that man cannot easily fake the way the gold leaf sits on the edge or the way the hinge feels when it clicks shut. Those things take time and they take a kind of love that a liar does not have. You have to look at the work and you have to feel the weight and you have to listen to the sound the lid makes when it hits the base.
I sat in my car after I hung up on my boss and I looked at the dashboard and I realized I was doing the same thing. I was waiting for a light to tell me it was time to move and I was waiting for a text to tell me I was not in trouble and I was letting the whole world pass by outside the window. The trees were turning orange and the wind was blowing the hair of a woman walking her dog and the world was full of life but I was looking at a screen. I was looking for a mark of safety and I was missing the actual day.
The Beast of Group Scrutiny
Group scrutiny is a strange beast because it feeds on itself and it grows until it eats the truth. If five people look at a mark and the first person says it is real then the next four people will find reasons to agree. They will say the ink looks old and they will say the shape is perfect and they will build a wall of words around the object until no one can see it anymore.
They are not looking at the porcelain and they are only looking at each other and they are looking for a reason to belong to the group that is right. It is a lonely way to be even when you are in a room full of people.
I went back into the house where Claire was still holding the bird and I asked her to let me see it. She handed it to me and it was cold and it was heavier than it looked and I did not turn it over. I looked at the way the blue paint bled into the white at the edges and I looked at the tiny yellow eyes of the bird and I saw that the artist had missed a spot near the wing.
The Beauty of the Human Mistake
It was a human mistake and it was a beautiful thing to see because it meant a person had sat at a desk and held a brush and thought about a bird. The stamp on the bottom did not matter because the work on the top told the real story.
“We need to learn how to look at the box before we look at the mark and we need to trust our own eyes more than we trust the big red book.”
— Observation from the Passenger Seat
If you find a piece that makes your heart beat a little faster then that is the only mark that truly matters in the end. A collection is not a list of names and dates and it is a map of the things that made you stop and look. If you only buy the stamp then you are just buying ink and clay and you are missing the soul of the craft.
Eyes on the Horizon
I started the car and I put it in gear and I did not look at the phone. I looked at the road and I looked at the sky and I drove away from the curb without waiting for a sign. My boss will call me back or he will not and the teenager will learn to drive or he will not but I am going to keep my eyes on the horizon.
I am going to look at the paint on the bird and I am going to feel the weight of the day in my hands and I am not going to let a matching mark make the rest of my life go quiet. It is a big world and it is full of beautiful things that do not have a name on the bottom and I think I am finally ready to see them.